Eye Records 2 CD Label : “Eye” Records Catalogue : #65-66 2Disc Length : 79:44 / 77:54 Source : Soundboard Recordings Date/Venue : Studio Outtakes / Demo / Other Sound Quality : VG- / EX+ Year Of Release : 2008 |
Comments
Fink's
Comments (rates this release 4.5/5.0)
The majority of the content contained in this release is already
freely circulating amongst collectors on various titles, and whilst it's always
good to have everything worth having on a single release, one can't help but
feel that this is an out-and-out attempt to grab some easy cash. Everything on
here which appeared on previous releases appears to be identical with no attempt
at mastering/cleaning/tweaking the audio in any way, and "Eye" have credited
themselves with being the first to release tracks such as the 14:04 version of
'Computer Blue' by using terms such as "was never circulating...until now" -
blatantly untrue as it has been lifted directly from the Pure Funk release '30
Years Of Unreleased Funk Vol. 1', as have the numerous tracks intended for the
I'll Do Anything soundtrack - simply lifted from the Pure Funk release and
placed on here with zero audible improvement. Not cool.
That said, Disc 1 does also have it's fair share of items which (thus far)
haven't appeared on a bootleg release, including the instrumental sax version of
'Damn U' taken from a WB test pressing, and various NPG Music Club / 3121.com
"demo" tracks and alternate versions. The exception to this is a 7:44
instrumental version of 'DMSR' titled 'San Jose Jam' made available in the NPGMC
Glam Slam VIP room taken from a Musicology tour soundcheck in San Jose from
September 2004 (albeit a mono recording). The opening 12 tracks on Disc 2
contain the cancelled Tamar "Milk & Honey" album which was pulled from release
in 2006. With the exception of the closing track, Disc 2 features an all-female
collection of material. Bria Valente's dire 3121.com "Jam Of The Week" from
October 2007 is followed by 3 uncirculating (until now) outtakes from the
Martika's Kitchen sessions - sung by Martika, and supposedly written by Prince,
it's clear why they remained off the album.
The most interesting item on Disc 2 is the 1 minute instrumental track titled
"Clouds" dating from the 1960's and credited to Delia Derbyshire - interesting
in the respect that the atmospheric intro proceeding the "Rain is wet and sugar
is sweet" speech on 'Eye No' (and the Lovesexy album) appears to be this
particular unknown early piece of electronic music - certainly Prince never gave
credit for it's usage. The release ends with a number of instrumental excerpts
of 'Xenophobia' which were briefly posted at NPGMC in December 2001. The audio
quality throughout is of a high standard with the only tracks suffering slightly
are Disc 1 (2-8), and due to the nature of the recordings, it's easily
overlooked and doesn't affect the release overall. There are intermittent issues
with mono/stereo recordings, but theses are presented as they were made
available on NPGMC or 3121.com and no fault of "Eye" Records.
The booklet accompanying the release is a hefty 26 pages with a fair amount of
detail and explanation given to each inclusion - great attention to detail and
very thorough, especially the pages dedicated to the doomed Tamar project.
Overall this isn't a bad release by any means, it's just that Disc 1 relies far
too heavily on what was already freely available. A number of the other
inclusions are questionable (Bria Valente, anyone?) however as outtake / studio
releases are something of a rarity nowadays, I guess this is all one can expect.